The disney version allows cinderella to have a room in the top of the house (so they are a little kinder than the original family) but the grimm's version allows her to have no bed instead she must sleep in the kitchen, as the maid, in front of the hearth where it is warmest. Comparisons: perrault version: grimm version: lee version: time setting: once upon a time: once upon a time: two hundred years ago: mother: already dead when story begins. Over the centuries, many different versions of the cinderella story have been some are written with children in mind while others are strictly for adults three popular versions are those of jakob and wilhelm grimm, tanith lee, and walt disney most parents know that it is very important to. Good triumphs evil: cinderella cinderella, as told by jacob and wilhelm grimm in household tales, is a tale most of us are familiar with most know the version of the tale as told in the disney classic animated film.
The grimm brothers' version of cinderella is much more violent than the classic disney version it features the same young girl but with a neglectful father as well as an abusive stepfamily. Well known for their bloody tales, the brothers grimm told the story of cinderella in a way that little children should never hear little red riding hood has a very clever grandmother that saves her life (as opposed to perrault's version, in which both women die. Comparison of two versions of cinderella: grimm vs perrault 979 words | 4 pages stories that we have seen as young adults and even as adults are original folk tale stories that have been modified and rewritten to accommodate our new cultures.
Cinderella comparison: grimm version vs i feel that these two stories very nicely represent allison lurie's views of fairy tales i feel this way because lurie stated that fairy tales are stories of magic and transformation. Brothers grimm's cinderella versus walt disney cinderella what was cut out of the movie cinderella was a folk tale rewritten in 1697 by brothers grimm in 1950 walt disney productions made their interpretation of the brothers grimm tale and made a movie. A comparison of cinderella in everafter and the brothers grimm version pages 1 words 574 cinderella, the everafter version, cinderella film version, brothers grimm.
Cinderella, aarne-thompson-uther folktale type 510a and related stories of persecuted heroines translated and/or edited by d l ashliman. Cinderella stories are a great way to have students learn about fables and folktales from different cultures many students are familiar with the disney version, but have not yet begun to explore how authors can write the same story in different ways there are so many versions, you can pick the. My wife recently wrote an essay for her college english class comparing disney's 1950 film cinderella to the literary version told by the grimm brothers the contrast was revealing.
Two versions, perrault's and disney's, had the fairy godmother magically made it possible for cinderella to go to the ball, whereas in grimm's it was the spiritual tree and the doves in contrast to the others grimm's version was the only one where there was just a little presence of cinderella's mother. Grimm brothers cinderella vs disney the comparison between cinderellas' mother, and her stepmothercinderellas' mother, whether directly or indirectly, is in fact a large part of the story. But cinderella is not just one story more than 500 versions have been found—just in europe the tale's origins appear to date back to a chinese story from the ninth century, yeh-shen almost every culture seems to have its own version, and every storyteller his or her tale.
The oldest known version of the cinderella story is the ancient greek story of rhodopis, a greek courtesan living in the colony of naucratis in egypt, whose name means rosy-cheeks. This version of the cinderella story tells the the story of two sisters who approach the king's search for a wife differently while manyara is more concerned with position and power, nyasha is. Students will compare/contrast various versions of the cinderella story using think-pair-share, story element charting, carousel brainstorming, and semantic feature analysis students will think critically and hold grade-level appropriate dialogue about complex texts read aloud.